Roasted oysters with garlic cream, bacon lardons parmesan-herb crust from Preserved Restaurant in Saint Augustine, Florida
Agnes Lopez

Favorite Restaurants on Florida's Historic Coast

January 24, 2019

Known as the “Historic Coast,” this stretch of Atlantic Florida has a distinctive cooking style all its own. Local seafood, including Mayport shrimp, features on many menus, as do such Southern specialties like gumbo and grits. Spanish-inspired dishes like Minorcan chowder reflect the centuries that Florida was a Spanish colony, and a locavore movement in the region delivers freshly milled rice from the Congaree and Penn rice farm and drinks mixed with spirits brewed by the St. Augustine Distillery. Here are our favorite tables.

Cap’s on the Water

This popular casual-dining restaurant is located on the Intracoastal Waterway. Seafood, including steamed oysters and fried Mayport shrimp, stars on its menu.

Cap’s on the Water
4325 Myrtle Street, St. Augustine. Tel. (904) 824-8794

Preserved Restaurant

Porch seating at Preserved Restaurant in St. Augustine Agnes Lopez

Chef Brian Whittington’s fashionable restaurant set in a beautifully restored 19th-century house in the historic Lincolnville neighborhood of St. Augustine is one of the best on the Historic Coast. Don’t miss the bouillabaisse, or the sweet-potato bread pudding.

Preserved Restaurant
102 Bridge Street, St. Augustine. Tel. (904) 679-4940

Eleven South

Dishes like butternut squash and Gouda arancini, grilled Spanish octopus, and local grouper with orzo, sweet corn and sun-dried tomatoes feature on the menu of this easygoing modern American bistro. The wine list is unexpectedly good.

Eleven South
216 11th Avenue South, Jacksonville Beach. Tel. (904) 241-1112

Restaurant Medure

Charred Spanish octopus with roasted beets, guanciale and red pepper puree from Restaurant Medure in Ponte Vedra Beach Restaurant Medure

If you want to enjoy your wine, this well-regarded contemporary restaurant is a short ride from the Ponte Vedra resort. Imaginative dishes include duck confit strudel, and casarecce with calamari and ’nduja (soft Calabrian sausage). And the apple bundt cake is terrific.

Restaurant Medure
818 A1A North, Ponte Vedra Beach. Tel. (904) 543-3797

Palm Valley Fish Camp

Specializing in seafood, this friendly, laid-back restaurant is ideal for a lunch of regional dishes such as fried green tomatoes, pimiento cheese, and fried alligator tail with datil pepper aioli.

Palm Valley Fish Camp
299 Roscoe Boulevard North, Ponte Vedra Beach. Tel. (904) 285-3200

Get Inspired for Your Next Adventure

Register to sample:

  • One-of-a-kind itineraries
  • Inspirational travel articles
  • Free e-newsletter from our editors
All fields are required.
By Hideaway Report Editor Hideaway Report editors travel the world anonymously to give you the unvarnished truth about luxury hotels. Hotels have no idea who they are, so they are treated exactly as you might be.
Learn more...
Contact a Travel Advisor
Hideaway Report members have access to travel advisors at our partner Andrew Harper Travel. Learn More
Call Andrew Harper Travel:
1 (800) 375-4685